Cleaning PCBAs Using Ultrasound or Spraying: Which Process Fits Which Requirement?

time for a fact checkUltrasonic or Spray Cleaning


On the Test Bench: Which Process for Which Requirement?

Ultrasonic and spray cleaning are proven and widely used processes for removing flux from the surface of assemblies. But as a manufacturer, how do you decide which of the two methods is the right one for the cleaning process you need? It depends on the individual cleaning requirements. In addition to the question "How clean should it be?", these factors also play an important role when deciding on a cleaning process: the production throughput and therefore the size of the system, as well as the ability to automate the process.

One half of a circuit board shows ultrasonic cleaning and the other half shows the spray process for cleaning assemblies. | © Zestron

Do you need guidance? The fact check gives you a compact overview of the cleaning processes and different systems and tells you which process is suitable for which cleaning challenge.

Watch the Fact Check in the Video 

fact check to readUltrasonic And Spraying


On the Test Bench: Cleaning Processes And Systems

Ultrasonic Cleaning - Immerision in Several Tanks

PCBAs are cleaned using ultrasound in immersion tanks with ultrasound generators. The ultrasound emitted creates growing, so-called cavitation bubbles in the cleaning bath, which implode and thus remove impurities from the assembly.
The cleaning systems consist of several tanks for cleaning, rinsing and drying.

On display is a semi-inline cleaning system that uses ultrasound to clean electronic assemblies.
Ultrasonic cleaning system consisting of several tanks

Are you concerned that ultrasound could damage sensitive components?
Find the answers in this fact check


Spraying Systems - "Dishwasher" or Fully Automated?

There are two types of spraying systems. So-called batch systems work in a similar way to a dishwasher and consist of a single chamber for cleaning, rinsing and drying. The assemblies either stand in baskets or are clamped in product carriers. Depending on the configuration, the system has two to four spray arms that either rotate or move linearly over the assemblies.

A Zestron engineer stands at the batch cleaning system in the machine test centre and inspects the cleaned PCBs. | © @The Sour Cherry Fotografie - Michaela Curtis
Batch system based on the "dishwasher" principle with rotating spray arms

There are also inline systems that can be integrated fully automatically into the production line. Here, the assemblies pass through the system on a conveyor belt and are cleaned under fixed spray arms.

Inline Cleaning Machine - Cleaning pcbs
Fully automatic inline system with fixed spray arms

the fact checkWhich Process for Which Requirement?

Removing flux and other contaminants from electronic assemblies in spray or ultrasonic cleaning systems is a proven and established procedure. Nevertheless, there are reservations, frequently asked questions or assumptions about both processes and the cleaning machines.

We have already resolved some of these in our fact checks.

In any case, the decisive factor is the individual cleaning challenge or question posed by the manufacturer, e.g. where on the assembly does it need to be clean and how? However, the following three factors should also not be underestimated:

  • Throughput or cycle time of a machine

  • The size of the system or its space requirements

  • The degree of automation of a system and the manual effort required to operate it

We do the fact check and have tested standard series cleaning systems on the market to find out which process is the right one for which requirement.

Curious to Find Out More? Then Enquire Now And Find Out More About:

  • The cleaning principle of spray and ultrasonic systems.

  • How the systems differ in terms of size, throughput or cycle time and automation options.

  • The structure of our cleaning tests and the results.

  • Which process is best suited for which cleaning challenge, e.g. sub-component cleaning.

Requesting Now

Discover More Fact Checks:

The picture shows two cleaning systems for electronic assemblies. A linear and a rotating spray arm cleaning system.

Do PCB Washing Processes with Linear or Rotating Spray Arms Clean Better?

Check the Fact

A system that works on the principle of a dishwasher is shown for cleaning printed circuit boards.

Does Shadowing Always Occur in Dishwashers for PCBs?

Check the Fact

Two components are positioned next to each other and surrounded by an ultrasonic bath, one with sparkling stars for cleanliness and the other with lightning bolts for cleaning difficulties.

Does PCB Cleaning with Ultrasonic Damage Electronic Components

Check the Fact

A green circuit board is surrounded by water and air bubbles.

Which Immersion Processes do Exist and How Suitable are they for Cleaning Assemblies?

Check the Fact

Electronics cleaning with pressurised flow in a cleaning system. | © Zestron

What is More Important for Achieving a Good Cleaning Result? Pressure or Flow Rate?

Check the Fact

An assembly is surrounded by rinsing water and cleaned.

Rinsing Water: What Must be Considered in Water Management and Quality Monitoring?

Check the Fact

The picture illustrates the challenge of low-standoff cleaning, in which flux and production residues must be removed in areas that are difficult to access | © Zestron

Low-Standoff-Cleaning - How to Overcome the Challenge?

Check the Fact

A circuit board is surrounded by rinsing water and a hand with a thumb upwards can be seen to show the quality of the assembly cleaning. | © @Zestron

PCB Cleaning: How Do You Produce Rinse Water of the Best Possible and Consistent Quality?

Check the Fact

A circuit board is in the cleaning process and is being dried.  | © Zestron

After Rinsing Comes Drying: How to Ensure PCBAs are Truly Dry

Check the Fact

Carriers in PCBA Cleaning – What Matters in Design and Application

Check the Fact